Introdutcion
“Papa What If” is a heartfelt duet by country artist Rory Feek and his young daughter, Indiana (Indy), released as a Father’s Day tribute in June 2022. The song is a reimagining of Shel Silverstein’s classic “Daddy What If,” originally performed by Bobby Bare and his son in the early 1970s. Rory, who first heard the song as a child, had previously performed it with his eldest daughter, Heidi, in the 1990s. He introduced the song to Indy by typing out the lyrics and illustrating them with drawings, substituting “Papa” for “Daddy” to reflect their relationship.
The duet captures a tender exchange between father and daughter, with Indy posing imaginative “what if” questions and Rory responding with gentle reassurances. Their voices harmonize over a simple acoustic arrangement, creating an intimate atmosphere that highlights their bond. The song was recorded in a studio with producers Ben Isaacs and Matt Johnson, and a music video was filmed on the porch of their Tennessee farmhouse, showcasing their genuine connection.
“Papa What If” resonates with listeners for its authenticity and emotional depth, reflecting themes of love, curiosity, and the special relationship between a parent and child. The song stands as a testament to the enduring power of familial bonds and the joy found in shared musical moments.