Introduction
“Brand New Whiskey” appears as Track 5 on Brooks & Dunn’s fifth studio album, If You See Her, released in 1998 via Arista Nashville . Written by Gary Stewart and Mary Lou Stewart—both known for their rich contributions to ’70s and ’80s country—it stood out as a deep cut rather than a single.
Musically and thematically, “Brand New Whiskey” fits squarely within the duo’s honky‑tonk traditions: its smooth, mid‑tempo groove and refined melody support a lyrical concept celebrating a fresh start—drinking a “brand new whiskey” named after a departed lover. Notably, it doesn’t condemn drinking but instead depicts it as a tribute, a familiar theme in country’s exploration of heartbreak and remembrance, aligning with the album’s broader emotional palette .
Critical response, while limited given its status as an album track, places “Brand New Whiskey” among the hidden gems in If You See Her. One retrospective appreciation notes it as “one of my favorites from the album … with its smooth melody and the idea of creating a new brand of whiskey … for a man to hold on to when his woman has left” . This comment highlights the song’s standout craftsmanship in songwriting and performance, even without chart exposure.
Contextually, the song complements lead singles like “If You See Him/If You See Her,” “How Long Gone,” and “Husbands and Wives” — all of which topped country charts. It underscores Brooks & Dunn’s ability to balance radio hits with heartfelt album tracks that deepen the listener’s emotional experience.
Overall, “Brand New Whiskey” embodies the duo’s signature blend—combining honky‑tonk roots, polished production, and narrative depth—making it a memorable, though under‑celebrated, piece of the If You See Her era.