Introduction
“Don’t Leave, I Think I Love You” is a standout deep cut by country superstar Toby Keith, featured on his critically acclaimed eighth studio album Shock’n Y’all, released November 4, 2003, via DreamWorks Records . Co‑written by Keith and fellow country star Ronnie Dunn—half of the legendary Brooks & Dunn duo—this song showcases the emotional breadth of Keith’s songwriting partnerships .
While Shock’n Y’all debuted at No. 1 on both the Billboard 200 and Top Country Albums charts and went on to earn a 4× Platinum certification in the U.S. , its title tracks—like “I Love This Bar,” “American Soldier,” and “Whiskey Girl”—typically received the most radio play . Nevertheless, “Don’t Leave, I Think I Love You” has emerged as a fan favorite, often praised as one of the album’s “best, catchiest country songs” that escape mainstream attention.
Blending a classic twang with a raw emotional core, the song diverges from Keith’s traditional bravado anthems. Instead, it delves into the vulnerability of romantic confession—an intimate, earnest appeal that balances heartfelt lyrics with Keith’s distinctive delivery. The track runs approximately 3:46, nestled among both studio and live recordings on the album .
Though it was never released as a single, it highlights Keith’s versatility: the ability to pivot from high-energy, patriotic bangers to introspective, melodic ballads. Moreover, collaborating with Ronnie Dunn points to the mutual respect between two of country music’s leading voices—a creative exchange that enhances the emotional weight of the song.
This hidden gem stands as a testament to Toby Keith’s multifaceted artistry. Even amid the 4×‑Platinum success and mainstream acclaim of Shock’n Y’all, “Don’t Leave, I Think I Love You” quietly resonates with listeners thanks to its heartfelt sincerity, strong songwriting partnership, and memorable melody.