Introduction
Rory + Indy – “Papa What If”: A Sweet Conversation Between Father and Daughter, Wrapped in Love and Wonder
“Papa What If” is a touching, intimate duet performed by singer-songwriter Rory Feek and his then‑eight‑year‑old daughter, Indiana (“Indy”). The song is a heartfelt cover of Shel Silverstein’s classic “Daddy What If,” originally recorded by Bobby Bare and his son in the early 1970s . Rory first encountered this song as a child growing up in Kansas, singing along with his father on family car rides . Over the years, “Daddy What If” became a cherished piece in Rory’s life—he later performed it with his eldest daughter, Heidi, onstage during the 1990s . When Indy expressed an interest in singing a real song alongside her papa, Rory knew exactly which song to revisit and adapted its title to “Papa What If” in honor of her nickname .
The recording process began in late 2021, as Rory, along with producers Ben Isaacs and Matt Johnson, decided to capture this father‑daughter moment in the studio . Ben Isaacs crafted the accompaniment at his Hendersonville studio, while Indy and Rory recorded their vocals in Columbia, creating a genuine and emotionally rich rendition. Inspired by the song’s simplicity, the duo later filmed a video at their Tennessee farmhouse—just Rory on the porch playing guitar as Indy sang with him, allowing the emotional weight of their bond to shine through .
In June 2022, the video premiered on Rory’s YouTube channel as a Father’s Day gift to the world—and especially to all fathers—prompting warm, heartfelt responses across social media . Facebook and other platforms echoed the sentiment, with one post calling it “a touching father‑daughter moment” and noting how the pair’s portrayal of familial love resonated deeply .