Introduction
“Who’s Cheatin’ Who” is a notable country music track that has experienced success in two distinct eras, thanks to its recordings by Charly McClain in 1980 and Alan Jackson in 1997. The song was penned by songwriter Jerry Hayes and first brought to life by McClain. Serving as the title track of her 1980 album under Epic Records, it was released as a single in November 1980, with “Love Scenes” as its B-side. The song’s narrative delves into themes of infidelity and trust, resonating with many and propelling it to become McClain’s first Number One hit on the Billboard country charts in early 1981.
Seventeen years later, Alan Jackson revisited “Who’s Cheatin’ Who,” infusing it with his signature style and introducing it to a new generation of country music enthusiasts. Featured on his album “Everything I Love,” Jackson’s rendition was released as a single in 1997. He adapted the song to a male perspective by adjusting the pronouns and incorporated extended electric guitar and piano solos, adding a fresh musical dimension to the classic track. Jackson’s version achieved significant acclaim, reaching number two on the Billboard country charts, underscoring the song’s enduring appeal.
The music video accompanying Jackson’s rendition further distinguished it. Directed by Brad Fuller and set in Concord, North Carolina, the video showcased Jackson alongside prominent NASCAR Ford drivers of the time, including Rusty Wallace, John Andretti, Jeremy Mayfield, Kenny Irwin Jr., Dale Jarrett, Mark Martin, Bill Elliott, and Ernie Irvan. This collaboration between country music and NASCAR not only highlighted Jackson’s affinity for motorsports but also broadened the song’s reach to diverse audiences.
The enduring success of “Who’s Cheatin’ Who” across different decades and artists underscores its timeless narrative and adaptability within the country music genre. Both McClain’s original rendition and Jackson’s cover have cemented the song’s status as a classic, reflecting the evolving landscape of country music while maintaining its core storytelling essence.