Introduction
“Papa What If” is a heartfelt father-daughter duet performed by country artist Rory Feek and his young daughter, Indiana (affectionately known as Indy). Released in 2022, their rendition is a reimagining of Shel Silverstein’s classic song “Daddy What If,” originally recorded by Bobby Bare and his son in the early 1970s. In this version, Rory and Indy replace “Daddy” with “Papa,” adding a personal touch that reflects their unique bond .
The song captures a playful and imaginative conversation between a child and her father, exploring a series of whimsical “what if” scenarios. Indy’s innocent questions are met with Rory’s comforting and poetic responses, highlighting the depth of their relationship. Their voices blend beautifully over a simple acoustic arrangement, creating an intimate and touching musical experience .
The inspiration for this duet came after Indy expressed a desire to sing with her father following one of his concerts. Rory, who had cherished the original song since childhood, saw this as an opportunity to share a special moment with his daughter. He taught Indy the song by typing out the lyrics and illustrating them with drawings, making the learning process engaging and fun for her .
Their collaboration is not only a musical endeavor but also a tribute to their family’s resilience and love. After the passing of Rory’s wife, Joey Feek, in 2016, Rory embraced his role as a single father, and music became a way to strengthen his bond with Indy. “Papa What If” stands as a testament to their enduring connection and the healing power of music within a family .
The accompanying music video, set on their farm’s porch, features Rory and Indy singing together as the sun sets, encapsulating the warmth and sincerity of their relationship. This touching performance has resonated with audiences, serving as a reminder of the preciousness of family bonds and the importance of cherishing shared moments .