“We’ve been through it all—money, fame, children, loss. But through it all, we’ve stayed anchored in each other.” — shared by Tricia Lucus. On a quiet morning out on the golf course, Toby Keith stood beside the woman who had been with him since long before the fame. In his arms was their tiny grandchild — and to him, it was moments like this that defined the true meaning of happiness.

Introduction Toby Keith’s “My List”, written by Tim James and Rand Bishop, is a reflective country...