Introduction
“Papa What If” is a heartfelt duet by country artist Rory Feek and his daughter, Indiana (affectionately known as Indy). This touching rendition is an adaptation of Shel Silverstein’s song “Daddy What If,” which was originally recorded by Bobby Bare and his son in the early 1970s. The song features a series of imaginative “what if” questions posed by a child, with the parent providing reassuring and loving responses.
Rory first encountered “Daddy What If” as an eight-year-old boy in Kansas, singing along with his father during car rides through cornfields. The song held special significance for him, leading him to perform it with his oldest daughter, Heidi, during shows in Texas when she was around the same age as Indy. This tradition continued with Indy, who expressed a desire to sing a song with her father after one of his concerts at their farm. Rory chose “Daddy What If,” modifying it to “Papa What If” to reflect Indy’s name for him. He taught her the song by typing out the lyrics and drawing illustrations to represent her parts, fostering a deep connection through their shared musical journey.
Their collaboration culminated in a live performance during a Christmas concert at their farm, where Indy joined Rory on stage, delighting the audience with their endearing exchange. The positive reception inspired Rory to record the song professionally with Indy. With the assistance of producers Ben Isaacs and Matt Johnson, they created a beautiful track that captured the warmth and intimacy of their bond. The accompanying music video, filmed on the porch of their farmhouse, showcases the genuine affection between father and daughter, offering a glimpse into their life together.
“Papa What If” serves as a testament to the enduring power of music in strengthening family ties and preserving cherished memories. Through this song, Rory and Indy not only honor their personal history but also invite listeners to reflect on the precious moments shared with loved ones. The simplicity of the acoustic arrangement, combined with the sincerity of their vocals, resonates deeply, making “Papa What If” a timeless piece that celebrates the special relationship between a parent and child.